Painting: How do painters get more Google reviews?

 

Painting: How Do Painters Get More Google Reviews?

Short answer: Ask every customer in person at the final walk-through, then send a direct link that same evening. Most painters do great work but get few reviews for one reason: they rarely ask at the right moment. That moment is when the customer is standing in a freshly painted room, smiling.

Reviews Decide Who Gets the Call

BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey asked 1,002 U.S. consumers how they use reviews:

  • 97% read reviews for local businesses.
  • 74% only care about reviews from the last three months.
  • 47% won’t use a business with fewer than 20 reviews.
  • 68% will only use a business rated four stars or higher.

Source: BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey

So, it isn’t enough to have good reviews from three years ago. Homeowners look for a steady stream of recent ones.

Great Work, Quiet Profile

Imagine a painter named Nina. Two crews. Clean lines, careful prep, and drop cloths on every floor. Customers love her.

Her Google profile shows 11 reviews. The newest is 14 months old.

A homeowner comparing painters sees Nina with 11 reviews and a competitor with 85, several from last month. The competitor gets the call. Nina’s work doesn’t get a chance to speak.

Nina’s problem wasn’t quality. It was asking. She felt awkward about it, so she sent a generic email a week after each job, when the customer had already moved on.

The Four-Step Review System

1. Ask in Person at the Walk-Through

When the customer says, “This looks great,” that’s the moment.

Nina now says:

“I’m so glad you like it. Reviews are how families like yours find us. Would you be willing to write a few lines on Google about how it went? I’ll text you the link tonight.”

Almost everyone says yes in that moment. Saying yes to a person standing in front of you is easy.

2. Text the Link the Same Evening

Not an email. A text, with a direct link that opens the review box on her Google profile.

Google gives every business this link in the profile settings. Nina adds a photo of the finished room to the text. It reminds the customer what they’re writing about.

3. Make It Easy to Say Something Useful

Nina’s text says:

“If it helps, you could mention the room we painted and the town.”

That gives the next homeowner real detail, like “Painted our living room and stairwell in Ketchum.”

4. Follow Up Once, Three Days Later

Send a short, friendly reminder. Then stop.

One reminder is helpful. Three is pestering.

Rules to Stay on the Right Side of Google

  • Keep reviews unpaid. Google’s rules forbid paying or discounting for reviews, and those reviews can be removed.
  • Ask every customer, including the quiet ones. Picking only the happiest customers breaks Google’s policies, too.
  • Leave the writing to real customers. Reviews from you, your staff, or your family break the rules.

Honest reviews from real customers are the only kind that last.

When the Customer Isn’t on Google

Some customers, often older ones, don’t have a Google account or feel unsure about writing online. Make it easy for them, too.

Offer to email the link so a grown child can help. Or ask if you can quote a line from their thank-you note on your website, with their first name and town.

A kind note on paper, shared with permission, still tells the next homeowner something true.

Reply to Every Review

The same BrightLocal survey found that 89% of consumers expect owners to respond to reviews. And 50% are unlikely to choose a business that uses templated or generic replies.

So, write each reply by hand. Use the customer’s first name. Mention the room or the color. Thank them for something specific.

For example:

“Thanks, Laura. That deep green in the dining room turned out beautifully, and your cat was a great supervisor.”

Two sentences, written by a real person.

When a bad review comes, reply calmly, once. Say what you’ll do to make it right. The next homeowner reads your reply more closely than the complaint.

What Changed for Nina

Here’s the reality check. Not every customer followed through.

Over eight months, Nina asked 80 customers. 47 left a review. That’s about 6 in 10, a strong rate, and it still means 4 in 10 said yes and then forgot.

Her profile went from 11 reviews to 58, with new ones arriving every week. Her rating stayed at 4.9.

Calls from her profile rose from about 10 a month to about 16. At her average job of $4,800, closing half of those six extra calls adds about $14,400 a month in work.

Your Review Checklist

  • ☐ Your direct review link saved on your phone
  • ☐ A short, word-for-word ask at every final walk-through
  • ☐ A text with the link and a photo, sent the same evening
  • ☐ A suggestion to mention the room and the town
  • ☐ One follow-up after three days, then stop
  • ☐ Every customer asked, including the quiet ones
  • ☐ A personal reply to every review within a week

Start With Your Next Job

You don’t have to fix the past. Start with the next walk-through. Ask in person, text the link that night, and do it on every job.

In 90 days, your profile will tell a different story.

What makes you trust one painter’s reviews more than another’s?

Thomas E. Lodato, J.D. — Scale Hawk Media Group

 

Share this Post

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top