Roofing: How Do Roofers Get More Leads Without Buying Shared Leads?
Short answer: Build leads you own. Every roof you finish can bring the next three jobs on the same street. A shared lead sends the same homeowner to three or four roofers at once, and the race goes to the lowest price. A lead you own reaches you alone.
What a Shared Lead Really Costs
Imagine a roofer named Tess. She runs two crews in a mid-size town. She spends $3,000 a month on a lead service. That buys about 35 leads, at roughly $85 each.
Tess wins 4 of those 35 jobs. That’s about $750 in lead cost for every roof she sells.
The bigger cost doesn’t show on the invoice. The same homeowner got three other calls within the hour. By the time Tess arrives with her ladder, the homeowner already has a price in hand. Tess either cuts her number or goes home.
So she isn’t buying customers. She’s buying a seat at an auction.
The Public Record on Lead Services
This isn’t only a hunch. In January 2023, the Federal Trade Commission ordered HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million to contractors. The FTC alleged the company told contractors its leads would match the work they do and the area they serve, when many did not. It also alleged the company claimed job rates it could not back up. (FTC press release)
Lead services can still work. Go in with your eyes open and your math done.
Five Sources of Leads You Own
1. The Street You’re Already On
When a crew tears off a roof, every neighbor hears it. Hang a short note on 50 doors on each side of the job.
Say who you are, what you’re doing next door, and when you’ll be done. Thank them for their patience with the noise. A friendly note beats a sales flyer.
2. A Yard Sign That Stays Up
Ask the homeowner if your sign can stay up for two weeks after the job. Put your phone number on it in big type.
Drivers read signs at 25 miles an hour, so keep it to your name, “Roofing,” and the number.
3. Your Google Business Profile
Post a photo of every finished roof, with the town name. Ask every happy customer for a review on the day the crew leaves.
Fresh photos and recent reviews tell a homeowner you’re working right now, nearby.
4. Real Estate Agents and Home Inspectors
Every home sale with an old roof calls for a roofer, fast. Agents hate surprises at closing.
Offer a quick written roof report within 48 hours of their call. Do this well three times, and the agent sends you the fourth.
5. Past Customers
Send every past customer a short note each spring. Offer a free check of flashing and gutters.
Some will find nothing wrong. Some will remember a neighbor who asked about roofers.
What the Door Note Says
Keep it short enough to read on the porch. Here’s a version Tess used:
“Hi, neighbor. We’re replacing the roof at 412 Maple this week. Sorry for the noise. We’ll be done by Friday, and we’ll sweep the street for nails before we leave. If you’ve wondered about your own roof, we’ll take a look at no charge. Tess, Ridgeline Roofing, 555-0142.”
Notice what it does. It apologizes for the noise. It promises a clean street. It invites a free look, with no pressure.
The neighbor sees the crew keep that promise all week. By Friday, the note has proof behind it.
What Happened When Tess Tried It
Here’s the honest part. The first 60 days brought almost nothing. Tess hung 800 notes a month and got two calls.
Month three brought six calls and one roof. Month four brought nine calls and three roofs. By month six, her own leads were selling 4 roofs a month, the same as the lead service.
She cut her lead budget in half, to $1,500. Her notes, signs, and photos cost about $400 a month. Her average roof stayed at $14,000. And she stopped walking into kitchens where three other roofers had already been.
Her close rate on her own leads ran close to 1 in 2. On shared leads, it had been about 1 in 9.
The reason is simple. A neighbor who watched her crew work, sweep the yard, and haul off every nail has already decided to trust her.
Your Owned-Lead Checklist
- ☐ A door note for 50 houses on each side of every job
- ☐ A yard sign at every job, left up two weeks when the owner agrees
- ☐ Photos of every finished roof added to your Google Business Profile, with the town name
- ☐ A review request sent on the day the crew leaves
- ☐ Three real estate agents and two home inspectors who have your cell number
- ☐ A spring note to every past customer
- ☐ A simple tracker: where each call came from, and which ones turned into jobs
The Reality Check
Owned leads are slower. They take two to four months to build. A new roofer with no past jobs may still buy leads to get started, and that’s a fair choice.
The goal is a business that can live without them, so every lead you buy is a choice, not a lifeline.
Track every call by source for 90 days. The numbers will tell you where your next dollar belongs.
What’s the best lead you ever got that cost you nothing at all?
Thomas E. Lodato, J.D. — Scale Hawk Media Group