We Paid 30% More for a Contractor, and It Was the Right Call
Strong contractors compete on trust, not price.
We once paid 30% more for a contractor. On purpose.
Two phone calls made the choice for us.
Here’s what we heard.
The Project
A few years back, my partners and I won the bid on an abandoned assisted living facility. It was a massive rehab. We were excited about the profit it could bring.
Two well-respected commercial contractors bid the job. One came in far lower.
Easy choice, right? Take the lower bid.
First, we called their references.
Contractor A (lower bid):
“The work got done, but it was rocky. Communication issues. The timeline slipped.”
Contractor B (higher bid):
“Smooth project from start to finish. Kept us informed. No surprises.”
We chose Contractor B. We paid 30% more. We never regretted it.
“Rocky” Is Expensive in Development
For a homeowner, a rocky project is stressful. For a developer, it hits the numbers directly.
On a rehab like this, the building contract is only part of the cost. While the work drags on, the owner keeps paying:
- Loan interest
- Insurance
- Property taxes
- Overhead
Every month of delay pushes back the day the building starts earning money. Lenders and investors expect updates. Surprises make every one of those talks harder.
So when a reference says “the timeline slipped” and “communication issues,” a developer hears something specific: more carrying cost, more of my time spent managing, and more risk of a bad surprise in a building that’s been sitting empty.
A lower bid can vanish fast in that math.
The contract price shows up on day one. The cost of a rocky job shows up month after month.
Trust Comes From What Others Say About You
Here’s what that choice taught me:
Contractors with strong reputations compete on trust, not price.
And trust comes from what past clients say about you when you’re not in the room. Your own pitch counts for far less.
Both contractors were well regarded. Both had the skills. On paper, they looked alike. The difference showed up in two short calls with people who had already lived through a project with each of them.
Those calls were worth more than both proposals combined.
How to Check References Like a Developer
If you’re hiring a contractor, make the reference calls, and dig past “They were great.” Ask questions that show how the job really went:
- “Did the project finish on time and on budget? If not, what happened?”
- “How did they communicate? How often did you hear from them?”
- “What went wrong, and how did they handle it?” Every job has problems. You’re learning how they respond.
- “Were there surprises in cost or schedule?”
- “Would you hire them again?” Listen to how fast they answer.
- “What do you wish you’d known before you started?”
Listen to the tone as much as the words. “The work got done, but…” is a warning, even said politely.
Real enthusiasm is hard to fake.
Contractors: Your References Are Your Pricing Power
If you’re stuck competing on price, this story points at the real problem.
If your references aren’t raving about you, that’s your real competitive problem. Your pricing is a symptom.
Contractor B could charge 30% more and still win, because his past clients made the case for him.
That’s pricing power. You can build it on purpose:
1. Finish Strong
The last few weeks shape how a client remembers the whole job. A slow punch list can undo months of good work.
2. Ask for Feedback at Closeout
“How did we do? What could we have done better?”
You’ll hear what your references will say before a prospect does.
3. Choose Your References With Care, and Keep Them Warm
Thank them. Tell them when you’ve given out their name.
4. Fix Communication First
Look again at what each reference said. Communication, schedule, and surprises decided this job.
5. Collect the Stories
A short written testimonial from a happy client sells for you around the clock.
Reputation Lets You Charge More
We paid a 30% premium and never regretted it. On a complex rehab, the confidence that came with it was worth every dollar.
The lower bidder didn’t lose on price. He lost on what his last client said about him.
What would your last client say if a developer called them tomorrow?
Does your reputation let you charge more, or are you still stuck competing on price?
Contractors and owners, I’d like to hear from both of you in the comments.
Follow me for a new lesson from the job site every week.
SEO Information
SEO Title: Why Contractor References Matter More Than Price
SEO Description: On a major commercial rehab, we picked the contractor whose references raved, at a 30% premium. Why reputation beats the low bid.
Suggested Cover Image: An empty, partly gutted commercial building interior, ready for rehab.